The hardest Championship ever?

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.

BBCode is ON
[img] is OFF
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are OFF

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: The hardest Championship ever?

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by overseasTOON » Mon Feb 20, 2017 4:41 pm

ALF wrote:
Bodacious Benny wrote:
We will be a bottom half team next season and so long as we stay up I'm fine with that <ok>

I think Gibbs is alright tbh. Not amazing but a good player.
True, but I don't see the point in signing players who have peaked at that level and are on top level wages. Gibbs is just average at best, not very good going forward and average defensively.
I found this secret list https://realsport101.com/news/sports/es ... left-backs

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by ALF » Mon Feb 20, 2017 4:38 pm

Bodacious Benny wrote:
ALF wrote:
Gibbs won't be replacing Baines, he'll be lucky to get a PL move. Maybe a bottom half team will take a punt on him. The only reason though is because he is at Arsenal, he's not a good player at all.
We will be a bottom half team next season and so long as we stay up I'm fine with that <ok>

I think Gibbs is alright tbh. Not amazing but a good player.
True, but I don't see the point in signing players who have peaked at that level and are on top level wages. Gibbs is just average at best, not very good going forward and average defensively.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Tsi » Mon Feb 20, 2017 4:33 pm

Bodacious Benny wrote:
ALF wrote:
Gibbs won't be replacing Baines, he'll be lucky to get a PL move. Maybe a bottom half team will take a punt on him. The only reason though is because he is at Arsenal, he's not a good player at all.
We will be a bottom half team next season and so long as we stay up I'm fine with that <ok>

I think Gibbs is alright tbh. Not amazing but a good player.
Pretty much like Dummett imo, we'd need a upgrade on either of those as both would be good as squad players but why buy gibbs if you have Dummett.
Hjl wrote:One goal does not make a great finisher. Tiote.
Just as well he's a defender then.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by bodacious benny » Mon Feb 20, 2017 4:28 pm

ALF wrote:
Bodacious Benny wrote:Yeah I've no issue keeping Dummet as a squad player.

Ideally I'd love us to sign someone like Gibbs for LB (out of contract at Arsenal this summer) if we go up but it'd probably unlikely. Could see him replacing Baines at Everton.
Gibbs won't be replacing Baines, he'll be lucky to get a PL move. Maybe a bottom half team will take a punt on him. The only reason though is because he is at Arsenal, he's not a good player at all.
We will be a bottom half team next season and so long as we stay up I'm fine with that <ok>

I think Gibbs is alright tbh. Not amazing but a good player.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Hjl » Mon Feb 20, 2017 3:59 pm

One goal does not make a great finisher. Tiote.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by ALF » Mon Feb 20, 2017 3:30 pm

Slight deflection, it was going places anyway though.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Ramone » Mon Feb 20, 2017 3:26 pm

Huge deflection

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by ALF » Mon Feb 20, 2017 3:14 pm

Hjl wrote:
Bodacious Benny wrote:Yeah I've no issue keeping Dummet as a squad player.

Ideally I'd love us to sign someone like Gibbs for LB (out of contract at Arsenal this summer) if we go up but it'd probably unlikely. Could see him replacing Baines at Everton.

It would be nice to have an attacking left back. Dummet is basically another center back just stuck on the wing. His crossing, passing, pace and shooting are all poor. He is tall and can tackle. It's pretty obvious he's just a failed center back, atleast in my opinion.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by ALF » Mon Feb 20, 2017 3:10 pm

Bodacious Benny wrote:Yeah I've no issue keeping Dummet as a squad player.

Ideally I'd love us to sign someone like Gibbs for LB (out of contract at Arsenal this summer) if we go up but it'd probably unlikely. Could see him replacing Baines at Everton.
Gibbs won't be replacing Baines, he'll be lucky to get a PL move. Maybe a bottom half team will take a punt on him. The only reason though is because he is at Arsenal, he's not a good player at all.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Colly » Mon Feb 20, 2017 3:03 pm

If you ask Jamie Carragher that's true of all fullbacks. He's pretty quick though for a defender and his passing isn't bad at all, I won't argue that he's not a defensively minded fullback though.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Hjl » Mon Feb 20, 2017 2:17 pm

Bodacious Benny wrote:Yeah I've no issue keeping Dummet as a squad player.

Ideally I'd love us to sign someone like Gibbs for LB (out of contract at Arsenal this summer) if we go up but it'd probably unlikely. Could see him replacing Baines at Everton.

It would be nice to have an attacking left back. Dummet is basically another center back just stuck on the wing. His crossing, passing, pace and shooting are all poor. He is tall and can tackle. It's pretty obvious he's just a failed center back, atleast in my opinion.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by bodacious benny » Mon Feb 20, 2017 1:39 pm

Yeah I've no issue keeping Dummet as a squad player.

Ideally I'd love us to sign someone like Gibbs for LB (out of contract at Arsenal this summer) if we go up but it'd probably unlikely. Could see him replacing Baines at Everton.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by ALF » Mon Feb 20, 2017 1:32 pm

Colly wrote:
ALF wrote:
If we need the team to be well drilled and tough to beat next season then Dummett seems like a perfect choice at LB. We need a new number 10, Diame and Perez aren't consistent enough.
It just seems daft to me that people are saying replace Dummett when clearly we actually need to be replacing Haidara, Gamez etc, then letting Dummett and new left back fight for the position. It always feels like we're not allowed two left backs in the squad at the same time, and we usually get punished for it.
Agreed. Dummett is a great player to have in the squad, as first choice or even as back up if an improvement becomes available. Even to this day I still see people say Haidara is a really good player, he's literally shown nothing in 4 years. Gamez looks like a terrible signing. 31 years old, injury prone and looked poor when he's played. We need another LB to compete with Dummett, Lazaar was meant to be that player but that's not looking likely as yet so we'll need another in the summer.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Colly » Mon Feb 20, 2017 1:15 pm

ALF wrote:
Yacob wrote: I don't agree. You can't replace that many players in one summer. It has to be a slow process. If we bring in five or six good players, we will have more than enough to stay up. Look at Burnley. They have an average team, but are well drilled and pick up results. Rafa will have us doing something similar and we can grow a lot quicker due to having a world class manager and being a bigger club. I think we will be comfortable of relegation next year, even if we only make a few additions.

Gouffran, Dummett need to be replaced and we need a better number ten. Aside from that, our team will improve and is more than good enough to stay up.
If we need the team to be well drilled and tough to beat next season then Dummett seems like a perfect choice at LB. We need a new number 10, Diame and Perez aren't consistent enough.
It just seems daft to me that people are saying replace Dummett when clearly we actually need to be replacing Haidara, Gamez etc, then letting Dummett and new left back fight for the position. It always feels like we're not allowed two left backs in the squad at the same time, and we usually get punished for it.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by bodacious benny » Mon Feb 20, 2017 12:20 pm

Beatski wrote:what are you basing the Barlaser decision on?
He's developing quite nicely for me on FIFA.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by beatski » Mon Feb 20, 2017 11:49 am

what are you basing the Barlaser decision on?

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by ALF » Mon Feb 20, 2017 11:39 am

Yacob wrote:
Hjl wrote:
I agree whole heartedly. Just look at Leicester this season. On paper they are miles better than we are and they are in a relegation battle.

Honestly next season scares me a lot more than this one does. We are going to need to spend a lot in the summer and replace most of our team if we want to do ok.

lets look at our starting 11

Darlow (replace)
Yedlin (keep) Lascelles (keep) Clark (replace) Dummett (replace)
Ritchie (keep just) Hayden (replace) Shelvey (keep) Goufran (replace)
Perez (replace)
Gayle (replace)

so by my reckoning thats 7 replacements in just our starting 11 needed.

then if you look at the bench

Ameobi (replace)
Sterry (replace)
Lazaar (replace)
Sels (replace)
Haidara (keep)
Barlasar (replace)
Hanely (replace)
Mitro (replace <wah> )
I don't agree. You can't replace that many players in one summer. It has to be a slow process. If we bring in five or six good players, we will have more than enough to stay up. Look at Burnley. They have an average team, but are well drilled and pick up results. Rafa will have us doing something similar and we can grow a lot quicker due to having a world class manager and being a bigger club. I think we will be comfortable of relegation next year, even if we only make a few additions.

Gouffran, Dummett need to be replaced and we need a better number ten. Aside from that, our team will improve and is more than good enough to stay up.
If we need the team to be well drilled and tough to beat next season then Dummett seems like a perfect choice at LB. We need a new number 10, Diame and Perez aren't consistent enough.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Yacob » Mon Feb 20, 2017 11:22 am

Hjl wrote:
Bodacious Benny wrote:However difficult it is, we'd be in the flight of our lives in the PL next season if we go up. We're a long long way from even looking at being a top half side (assuming we go up) and 17th will be our aim next season. Desperately need to add quality in key areas, traditionally there used to always be a few sides in the PL that you could identify as the ones that 'should' go down. Those days are over and literally half the league could realistically see themselves as relegation candidates on any given season.
I agree whole heartedly. Just look at Leicester this season. On paper they are miles better than we are and they are in a relegation battle.

Honestly next season scares me a lot more than this one does. We are going to need to spend a lot in the summer and replace most of our team if we want to do ok.

lets look at our starting 11

Darlow (replace)
Yedlin (keep) Lascelles (keep) Clark (replace) Dummett (replace)
Ritchie (keep just) Hayden (replace) Shelvey (keep) Goufran (replace)
Perez (replace)
Gayle (replace)

so by my reckoning thats 7 replacements in just our starting 11 needed.

then if you look at the bench

Ameobi (replace)
Sterry (replace)
Lazaar (replace)
Sels (replace)
Haidara (keep)
Barlasar (replace)
Hanely (replace)
Mitro (replace <wah> )
I don't agree. You can't replace that many players in one summer. It has to be a slow process. If we bring in five or six good players, we will have more than enough to stay up. Look at Burnley. They have an average team, but are well drilled and pick up results. Rafa will have us doing something similar and we can grow a lot quicker due to having a world class manager and being a bigger club. I think we will be comfortable of relegation next year, even if we only make a few additions.

Gouffran, Dummett need to be replaced and we need a better number ten. Aside from that, our team will improve and is more than good enough to stay up.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by HowayTheLads » Fri Feb 17, 2017 9:23 pm

Hopefully they put out a strong side against Man City and see their momentum stopped a wee bit.

Re: The hardest Championship ever?

by Deleted User » Fri Feb 17, 2017 8:15 am

it's Huddersfield that worries me, in the last few weeks they've convincingly beat Brighton and beat Leeds - both teams walked over Huddersfield at the start of the season, they also beat QPR that we struggled to do - they're on fire at the moment and won both of their 6 pointers. They have Reading on 21st and us a couple of weeks after so they are getting all of their 6 pointers at the right time, form wise.

Top