Beatski wrote: ↑

Wed Feb 06, 2019 10:22 am

Remember Colo wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 05, 2019 2:57 pm

And Janmaat had good strikers to direct crosses and passes to. And the benefit of not having Benitez requiring more conservative and rigid tactics. Don't get me wrong, I was a huge fan of Janmaat, so I have no qualms saying he was great, but I'm just not sure if it's an even playing field.

I'd say the opposite, Yedlin has the benefit of a manager that has been able to coach him in to a defender, and he clearly has license to attack under Benitez (moreso now we play a back three)

Remember Colo wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 05, 2019 2:57 pm

Beatski wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 05, 2019 10:34 am

so like Yedlin then. Except Janmaat actually had end product (and a record amount of assists for a fullback for us), and didnt have the benefit of Benitez coaching him

And Janmaat had good strikers to direct crosses and passes to. And the benefit of not having Benitez requiring more conservative and rigid tactics. Don't get me wrong, I was a huge fan of Janmaat, so I have no qualms saying he was great, but I'm just not sure if it's an even playing field.

Slim999 wrote: ↑

Wed Feb 06, 2019 12:06 am

I'm just posting this to get us to page 4.

B
A
R
R
E
.ca

CIH wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 11:12 am

Colly wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 8:59 am

Yeah to be really clear I don't think he's horrific, he's just by far our defensive weak link in a back 4, and opposition sides know that. That for me isn't "the complete full back", and I think he's far better in his current position. He's definitely better than Danny Simpson. Don't get me started on Danny Simpson.

In terms of the big list for me Perch and Taylor weren't full backs, so Debuchy > Janmaat > Yedlin > Simpson for me. Not really buying this Janmaat is crap argument, he was at least as defensively solid as Yedlin and offered an awful lot going forward. He was excellent in his first season.

Just curious, what position do you think Taylor was best suited to? He was a bit of a jack of all trades I know, but I always saw him predominantly as a right back. Played a lot on the left in fairness. Perch we signed as a right back I think, but again was more of a utility player. His best position eventually became CDM though. Anita played a lot of games at right back as well in the last championship season, missed him out.

Beatski wrote: ↑

Tue Feb 05, 2019 10:34 am

ALF wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 5:50 pm

We conceded so many goals from his side because he was always getting caught up the field.

so like Yedlin then. Except Janmaat actually had end product (and a record amount of assists for a fullback for us), and didnt have the benefit of Benitez coaching him

ALF wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 5:50 pm

Toondes wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 4:54 pm

I liked Janmaat but he has zero positional sense

We conceded so many goals from his side because he was always getting caught up the field.

ALF wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 5:51 pm

Colly wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 8:59 am

Yeah to be really clear I don't think he's horrific, he's just by far our defensive weak link in a back 4, and opposition sides know that. That for me isn't "the complete full back", and I think he's far better in his current position. He's definitely better than Danny Simpson. Don't get me started on Danny Simpson.

In terms of the big list for me Perch and Taylor weren't full backs, so Debuchy > Janmaat > Yedlin > Simpson for me. Not really buying this Janmaat is crap argument, he was at least as defensively solid as Yedlin and offered an awful lot going forward. He was excellent in his first season.

He's a Premier League winner for a reason

Colly wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 8:59 am

Speedo wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 6:38 pm

I mean Yedlin is often vulnerable in the air, but I don't feel he's awful. I don't think he's a downgrade on say Janmaat or Danny Simpson, for example. And he adds a huge amount to us going forward, whether we're playing a 4 or a 3/5 at the back. For example - his driving run created the situation that lead to the penalty vs. City.

Yeah to be really clear I don't think he's horrific, he's just by far our defensive weak link in a back 4, and opposition sides know that. That for me isn't "the complete full back", and I think he's far better in his current position. He's definitely better than Danny Simpson. Don't get me started on Danny Simpson.

In terms of the big list for me Perch and Taylor weren't full backs, so Debuchy > Janmaat > Yedlin > Simpson for me. Not really buying this Janmaat is crap argument, he was at least as defensively solid as Yedlin and offered an awful lot going forward. He was excellent in his first season.

Toondes wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 4:54 pm

I liked Janmaat but he has zero positional sense

Beatski wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 10:36 am

ALF wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 8:05 pm

Debuchy probably the best followed by Yedlin? Simpson was solid enough for us. Janmaat was awful yet bizarrely popular. Taylor was poor at RB, had good delivery but wasn't good at all. Perch was committed but not great.

Janmaat was good yet bizarrely despised (symptomatic of that whole team, where the best players got the most crap). Especially because he got injured then broke his hand punching the ground because he was pissed off that he couldnt play, but at the same time he didnt care about playing? because why bother with logic? (and he didnt miss any games because of his hand, he missed them because of the aforementioned injury)

Like a much better version of Yedlin.

Colly wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 8:59 am

Debuchy > Janmaat > Yedlin > Simpson for me. Not really buying this Janmaat is crap argument, he was at least as defensively solid as Yedlin and offered an awful lot going forward. He was excellent in his first season.

Beatski wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 10:36 am

Like a much better version of Yedlin.

Colly wrote: ↑

Sat Feb 02, 2019 8:59 am

Speedo wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 6:38 pm

I mean Yedlin is often vulnerable in the air, but I don't feel he's awful. I don't think he's a downgrade on say Janmaat or Danny Simpson, for example. And he adds a huge amount to us going forward, whether we're playing a 4 or a 3/5 at the back. For example - his driving run created the situation that lead to the penalty vs. City.

Yeah to be really clear I don't think he's horrific, he's just by far our defensive weak link in a back 4, and opposition sides know that. That for me isn't "the complete full back", and I think he's far better in his current position. He's definitely better than Danny Simpson. Don't get me started on Danny Simpson.

In terms of the big list for me Perch and Taylor weren't full backs, so Debuchy > Janmaat > Yedlin > Simpson for me. Not really buying this Janmaat is crap argument, he was at least as defensively solid as Yedlin and offered an awful lot going forward. He was excellent in his first season.

ALF wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 8:05 pm

CIH wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 7:43 pm

Brings up an interesting question, at least for me. Last few years we've had quite a lot of turnover in rightbacks. Debuchy, Simpson, Janmaat, Ryan Taylor and Perch to an extent, and now Yedlin. Who do people think are the best? As mentioned above, Yedlin is definitely not a poor alternative to any of the others. I was never that bothered about losing Janmaat either, he was okay but not spectacular. I liked Debuchy but I don't think he ever really settled, and getting rid of him when we did was the right move. Simpson was limited but did his best, but he now has a premier league winners medal (how did that happen? ) so he wins! I miss Raylor's free kicks.

Debuchy probably the best followed by Yedlin? Simpson was solid enough for us. Janmaat was awful yet bizarrely popular. Taylor was poor at RB, had good delivery but wasn't good at all. Perch was committed but not great.

Speedo wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 6:38 pm

I mean Yedlin is often vulnerable in the air, but I don't feel he's awful. I don't think he's a downgrade on say Janmaat or Danny Simpson, for example. And he adds a huge amount to us going forward, whether we're playing a 4 or a 3/5 at the back. For example - his driving run created the situation that lead to the penalty vs. City.

CIH wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 8:44 pm

ALF wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 01, 2019 8:05 pm

Debuchy probably the best followed by Yedlin? Simpson was solid enough for us. Janmaat was awful yet bizarrely popular. Taylor was poor at RB, had good delivery but wasn't good at all. Perch was committed but not great.

Perch was crap when he signed for us, got 5 yellows in five games I think? But he evolved into Perchino