Howe under pressure?

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.

BBCode is ON
[img] is OFF
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are OFF

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: Howe under pressure?

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Don Sholeone » Wed Mar 20, 2024 6:29 pm

He's got to go now for me. I'll continue to support the team until the end of the season but I'll be very pissed off if he's still here beyond the summer. Howe has played a huge part in the derailing of this season and he needs to be called out on it. This Botman farce has to be the final straw, surely.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by lassassinblanc » Sat Mar 02, 2024 9:59 am

Some nagelsmann rumours floating

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Valentino's fast feet » Wed Feb 07, 2024 7:16 pm

Colly wrote:
Mon Feb 05, 2024 10:51 am
<ok>

Excellent all round. And that second last para on "who comes in?" is an excellent point. It's not as if there's a big surplus of available proven managers floating around, particularly considering we'd now be competing with Liverpool and Barcelona who are clearly bigger pulls. Mourinho has a recent record of failure in the PL and as a manager who supposedly guarantees trophies all he's managed in over a decade is a couple of 2nd/3rd tier cups. Pochettino isn't doing his reputation any good currently (though in fairness recruitment has been woeful). We really could be doing a lot worse considering everything.
No, who's on first. <gent>

That's a fair comment as well about the other jobs available that I didn't even really consider. Mostly because I don't think we will (or rather should) be looking for a new manager come the summer. I genuinely believe there isn't a manager available to us that will be a direct improvement on Howe. Of course I also believe Howe is the right man going forward, so a touch bias there. Kieran McKenna is a good up and coming manager with Ipswitch, it's likely he will be in the top division next season whatever happens. Michél is doing a fantastic job at City owned Girona, maybe he has a future in the premier league. But very much unproven both. Howe is proven, and is improving. Has his faults, but the main one is being a victim of his own success. Too good too quickly.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Remember Colo » Mon Feb 05, 2024 2:22 pm

I kinda hate that criticism of a manager immediately is immediate read as wanting to replace the manager - you can want to keep him while still levelling criticism for what feels like an obvious and repeating mistake. And I'll also clarify this is a big picture criticism, not something directed at the forum itself.

This particular run is frustrating because we know Howe to be incredibly analytical and precise with his tactics and performance review, and yet he feels to have a blindspot when it comes to BDB right now - and maybe it just speaks to him as a system manager stubbornly feeling most comfortable playing the players he trusts - even if they need rest or are out of form. Either way, it's a product of his success that we expect him to learn from these errors faster.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Colly » Mon Feb 05, 2024 10:51 am

<ok>

Excellent all round. And that second last para on "who comes in?" is an excellent point. It's not as if there's a big surplus of available proven managers floating around, particularly considering we'd now be competing with Liverpool and Barcelona who are clearly bigger pulls. Mourinho has a recent record of failure in the PL and as a manager who supposedly guarantees trophies all he's managed in over a decade is a couple of 2nd/3rd tier cups. Pochettino isn't doing his reputation any good currently (though in fairness recruitment has been woeful). We really could be doing a lot worse considering everything.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by UlversToon » Mon Feb 05, 2024 9:44 am

Valentino's fast feet wrote:
Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:44 pm
Bodacious Benny wrote:
Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:19 pm
Agree, more than happy for Howe to have next season. With probably no Europe (hopefully no ECL) and with new additions and less injuries then no reason why he won’t get us top 4 or 5 again.
I can understand why people wouldn't want it, but I actually disagree. It's a trophy we'd be in real contention for should we qualify this season. Not only that, but it will give us another season in Europe - in theory against "lesser" teams - to allow for the squad to gain much needed experience.

As for the overall Howe issue, I agree with those saying it's all a bit much at this time. He's an excellent manager that's still learning and improving, and has been fantastic for us overall. I wholly agree with the Burn/rotation issues, but there's not a manager out there that doesn't make mistakes, and we don't all see the full picture anyway, so it's easy to judge. Although he does need dropping for the next game haha. Someone mentioned it's Howe's first season in Europe, he's learning how to manage upwards and evolving alongside us, which I think is perfect. This season was always going to be a struggle, it would never be possible to upgrade the squad in one or two windows to be able to deal with four competitions, let alone the elite level with CL. We finished bottom from a difficult group, but didn't disgrace ourselves for the most part. Shown up by more experienced competitors, maybe.

And speaking of the draw, we've had some overall bad luck this season. Tonali's ban absolutely blindsided us, and has had a massive knock on effect. There are those who say we should've done better due diligence, or should've seen it coming etc - but hindsight is 20/20. The long list of injuries is partially bad luck, partially expected to a degree due to our high intensity play style and having much more games to play - many of them at a high level. Sure, some blame can be attributed to lack of rotation at times, I'll acknowledge that. However we are hardly the only team in the prem this season to have such injuries, it's a clear side effect of the longer stoppages and the ball being "in play" longer. Plus the whole intensity arguments, we are playing at a higher level and much of the squad haven't experienced that.

Mild silver lining of the ban and injuries is the emergence of Miley, who is far from the finished product but he's stepping up when given the chance, so fair play lad. My personal theory on Hall, and this is guesswork, that the loan to buy agreement involves appearances and/or % of minutes played, hence the random few minute cameos he got for a bit towards the end. Whether he's not showing enough in training, or the PSR issues are worse than we thought and we don't want to commit the 28m+ in the summer - it seems likely that Hall isn't part of our plans going forward.

For those who want to send Howe on his way in the summer, bring in someone "elite" to take is to the next level, who is that? Mourinho, Potter? I think we have in place a very excellent manager, who has his faults but will continue to grow and improve alongside our team that is growing and overall is improving. It seems easy to forget that it was only a couple years ago we had a manager that didn't believe in tactics, slagged off the fans and was quite happy to keep us "ticking along." Along with his quest to find the bacon, of course.

And yes, our huge improvement since then obviously isn't just to do with Howe, the money has played it's part. I'm sure most if not all of us would rather it be from a less deplorable source, but the money has helped and is needed. But Howe and his team have been just as important to our increasing improvement. Wasn't build in a day, and the fact that people can be almost understandably disappointed by being in europe, a cup quarter final and a current top half standing in the table shows just how far Eddie Howe has taken us. I think he's far from done just yet.
<applause> <ok>

Re: Howe under pressure?

by originallad » Mon Feb 05, 2024 9:34 am

Valentino's fast feet wrote:
Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:44 pm
Bodacious Benny wrote:
Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:19 pm
Agree, more than happy for Howe to have next season. With probably no Europe (hopefully no ECL) and with new additions and less injuries then no reason why he won’t get us top 4 or 5 again.
I can understand why people wouldn't want it, but I actually disagree. It's a trophy we'd be in real contention for should we qualify this season. Not only that, but it will give us another season in Europe - in theory against "lesser" teams - to allow for the squad to gain much needed experience.

As for the overall Howe issue, I agree with those saying it's all a bit much at this time. He's an excellent manager that's still learning and improving, and has been fantastic for us overall. I wholly agree with the Burn/rotation issues, but there's not a manager out there that doesn't make mistakes, and we don't all see the full picture anyway, so it's easy to judge. Although he does need dropping for the next game haha. Someone mentioned it's Howe's first season in Europe, he's learning how to manage upwards and evolving alongside us, which I think is perfect. This season was always going to be a struggle, it would never be possible to upgrade the squad in one or two windows to be able to deal with four competitions, let alone the elite level with CL. We finished bottom from a difficult group, but didn't disgrace ourselves for the most part. Shown up by more experienced competitors, maybe.

And speaking of the draw, we've had some overall bad luck this season. Tonali's ban absolutely blindsided us, and has had a massive knock on effect. There are those who say we should've done better due diligence, or should've seen it coming etc - but hindsight is 20/20. The long list of injuries is partially bad luck, partially expected to a degree due to our high intensity play style and having much more games to play - many of them at a high level. Sure, some blame can be attributed to lack of rotation at times, I'll acknowledge that. However we are hardly the only team in the prem this season to have such injuries, it's a clear side effect of the longer stoppages and the ball being "in play" longer. Plus the whole intensity arguments, we are playing at a higher level and much of the squad haven't experienced that.

Mild silver lining of the ban and injuries is the emergence of Miley, who is far from the finished product but he's stepping up when given the chance, so fair play lad. My personal theory on Hall, and this is guesswork, that the loan to buy agreement involves appearances and/or % of minutes played, hence the random few minute cameos he got for a bit towards the end. Whether he's not showing enough in training, or the PSR issues are worse than we thought and we don't want to commit the 28m+ in the summer - it seems likely that Hall isn't part of our plans going forward.

For those who want to send Howe on his way in the summer, bring in someone "elite" to take is to the next level, who is that? Mourinho, Potter? I think we have in place a very excellent manager, who has his faults but will continue to grow and improve alongside our team that is growing and overall is improving. It seems easy to forget that it was only a couple years ago we had a manager that didn't believe in tactics, slagged off the fans and was quite happy to keep us "ticking along." Along with his quest to find the bacon, of course.

And yes, our huge improvement since then obviously isn't just to do with Howe, the money has played it's part. I'm sure most if not all of us would rather it be from a less deplorable source, but the money has helped and is needed. But Howe and his team have been just as important to our increasing improvement. Wasn't build in a day, and the fact that people can be almost understandably disappointed by being in europe, a cup quarter final and a current top half standing in the table shows just how far Eddie Howe has taken us. I think he's far from done just yet.
<applause>

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Over The Line » Mon Feb 05, 2024 9:27 am

Howe has enough credit built up with me to play whoever he wants this season and as long as we don't get relegated finish wherever.

If the window shuts next season and we are starting with Burn, Miggy, Longstaff/Miley, Murphy then questions can start to be asked.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Valentino's fast feet » Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:44 pm

Bodacious Benny wrote:
Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:19 pm
Agree, more than happy for Howe to have next season. With probably no Europe (hopefully no ECL) and with new additions and less injuries then no reason why he won’t get us top 4 or 5 again.
I can understand why people wouldn't want it, but I actually disagree. It's a trophy we'd be in real contention for should we qualify this season. Not only that, but it will give us another season in Europe - in theory against "lesser" teams - to allow for the squad to gain much needed experience.

As for the overall Howe issue, I agree with those saying it's all a bit much at this time. He's an excellent manager that's still learning and improving, and has been fantastic for us overall. I wholly agree with the Burn/rotation issues, but there's not a manager out there that doesn't make mistakes, and we don't all see the full picture anyway, so it's easy to judge. Although he does need dropping for the next game haha. Someone mentioned it's Howe's first season in Europe, he's learning how to manage upwards and evolving alongside us, which I think is perfect. This season was always going to be a struggle, it would never be possible to upgrade the squad in one or two windows to be able to deal with four competitions, let alone the elite level with CL. We finished bottom from a difficult group, but didn't disgrace ourselves for the most part. Shown up by more experienced competitors, maybe.

And speaking of the draw, we've had some overall bad luck this season. Tonali's ban absolutely blindsided us, and has had a massive knock on effect. There are those who say we should've done better due diligence, or should've seen it coming etc - but hindsight is 20/20. The long list of injuries is partially bad luck, partially expected to a degree due to our high intensity play style and having much more games to play - many of them at a high level. Sure, some blame can be attributed to lack of rotation at times, I'll acknowledge that. However we are hardly the only team in the prem this season to have such injuries, it's a clear side effect of the longer stoppages and the ball being "in play" longer. Plus the whole intensity arguments, we are playing at a higher level and much of the squad haven't experienced that.

Mild silver lining of the ban and injuries is the emergence of Miley, who is far from the finished product but he's stepping up when given the chance, so fair play lad. My personal theory on Hall, and this is guesswork, that the loan to buy agreement involves appearances and/or % of minutes played, hence the random few minute cameos he got for a bit towards the end. Whether he's not showing enough in training, or the PSR issues are worse than we thought and we don't want to commit the 28m+ in the summer - it seems likely that Hall isn't part of our plans going forward.

For those who want to send Howe on his way in the summer, bring in someone "elite" to take is to the next level, who is that? Mourinho, Potter? I think we have in place a very excellent manager, who has his faults but will continue to grow and improve alongside our team that is growing and overall is improving. It seems easy to forget that it was only a couple years ago we had a manager that didn't believe in tactics, slagged off the fans and was quite happy to keep us "ticking along." Along with his quest to find the bacon, of course.

And yes, our huge improvement since then obviously isn't just to do with Howe, the money has played it's part. I'm sure most if not all of us would rather it be from a less deplorable source, but the money has helped and is needed. But Howe and his team have been just as important to our increasing improvement. Wasn't build in a day, and the fact that people can be almost understandably disappointed by being in europe, a cup quarter final and a current top half standing in the table shows just how far Eddie Howe has taken us. I think he's far from done just yet.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by bodacious benny » Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:19 pm

Agree, more than happy for Howe to have next season. With probably no Europe (hopefully no ECL) and with new additions and less injuries then no reason why he won’t get us top 4 or 5 again.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by beatski » Sun Feb 04, 2024 10:15 pm

Think it's massively unfair on Howe to already be talking about his successor. he saved us from relegation then over performed and got us top 4 last season. Then the first bad spell and people want him out the door to be replaced by some mythical elite manager that would be falling over themselves to join

I know it's been done to death, but there are extenuating circumstances to our underperformances too; injuries and a ban and an incomplete squad have meant he's not been able to play the way he wants. Plus it being Howe's first season managing in Europe as well so it will have been a learning curve on that front

(As an aside about our squad, doesn't matter who the manager would be, our squad is at least one window away from being properly rounded and we were always likely to encounter problems because of that. We probably needed 8 signings in the summer, which was obviously impossible, and the club have IMO gambled on the 4 best deals rather than the 4 most needed in order to maximise the budget in the long term which with hindsight has obviously backfired in the short term, where similar gambles in the past have paid off.)

He deserves at least next season, with lessons learned, hopefully a much smaller injury list and a few more signings to enable our squad to compete at the level our fans are seemingly already demanding we perform at consistently.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by bodacious benny » Sun Feb 04, 2024 9:52 pm

We’d be stupid to turn down £100m for Bruno tbf. He’s not irreplaceable.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Don Sholeone » Sun Feb 04, 2024 9:50 pm

I think everyone would love to do a Leicester, but chances of that are very very slim. Football has evolved, for sustained success you need to be ruthless, we will have some long term players still but it's not going to be guaranteed to be a Bruno etc. im actually fully prepared to see him leave this summer, it feels inevitable, he's our first real asset that will bring in a huge fee that will transform the side.

In terms of a manager, the only real long term ones we will have are ones that can reach a Pep/Klopp level.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by bodacious benny » Sun Feb 04, 2024 9:28 pm

Selling players is part of football. Did Liverpool want to sell Suarez or Coutinho for big money? Probably not, but it enabled them to push on and improve the rest of the team. Villa fans didn’t want to sell Grealish but they’re in a hell of a stronger position now as it enabled them to buy. If Bruno goes for £100m in summer then so be it, it’s clear that if / when that happens it’ll enable to replace him and sign another elite level player to put us in a stronger position.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by seaside nipper » Sun Feb 04, 2024 9:25 pm

Last paragraph is my point entirely
Time line and ambition takes working, under FFP constraints and PSR there is no route to instant success.
The club and the fan demographic is now in flux, people imo need to be pragmatic.
As for an elite manager…….no clue
Any managerial appointment is a massive gamble.
EH is the incumbent, up to him to keep the slot.
He’s currently on a dip after his season of overreach in 2023 so imo he has to turn scoring four home goals into wins and not enigmatic draws.
Roller coaster continues.
C’est la vie…….

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Colly » Sun Feb 04, 2024 9:22 pm

Is it controversial to say that that sounds awful?

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Don Sholeone » Sun Feb 04, 2024 9:10 pm

Don't get me wrong I think he's a great manager, but if we are to get to the point the club aims to be at we need more than a great manager, if they are serious about us taking that next step then we need an elite manager, I see too many flaws in Howe for him to be that guy for us, i think the right move is to move him on in the summer in an amicable way if possible.

There is always a lot of talk about being realistic, for some fans they might be happy to have the "team that tries" mantra. But end of the day PIF are almost pushing us towards the realm of a £1 billion investment (including purchase fee) they will want more than just a team of trier's and that's the true realism of the situation. The club is evolving, there is a real and very serious ambition now. There will be no room for sentimentality going forward, the likes of Howe, Joelinton, Trippier, Bruno, etc. will be gone sooner rather than later, some even this coming summer.

I think fans will need to learn to not get too attached, the club will soon be in a realm that no Newcastle fan has seen before with our club, ruthlessness will be common place soon enough.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by seaside nipper » Sun Feb 04, 2024 8:48 pm

Don Sholeone wrote:
Sun Feb 04, 2024 6:02 pm
Not looking for instant gratification, just would be nice to beat teams like Everton, Bournemouth, Forest, Luton etc. after we have had 400-500m spent on the team, would be nice to see £60m worth of talent not stuck on the bench behind a badly out of form player. Would be nice to have a team set up that isn't constantly overran in midfield since pre season. Would have been nice have not seen our 11 best players ran into the ground in the space of 3/4 months.
Totally get that , EH has had his moments good and bad.
Issue for me is the growing number of malcontents that seem to think that since the takeover we have some kind of entitlement to be Top 4 and pressing for titles.
It’ll come , but not to some folks expected timetable.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by bodacious benny » Sun Feb 04, 2024 6:27 pm

Could be worse, could be Chelsea.

Re: Howe under pressure?

by Don Sholeone » Sun Feb 04, 2024 6:02 pm

Not looking for instant gratification, just would be nice to beat teams like Everton, Bournemouth, Forest, Luton etc. after we have had 400-500m spent on the team, would be nice to see £60m worth of talent not stuck on the bench behind a badly out of form player. Would be nice to have a team set up that isn't constantly overran in midfield since pre season. Would have been nice have not seen our 11 best players ran into the ground in the space of 3/4 months.

Top